bookmark_borderDeveloper Introduction to Maintaina Horde

This introduction is targeted at developers with little or outdated prior Horde knowledge. Having worked with any Backend Development Framework in any language can help. While a lot of these facts can be found in Wikis or previous article, others are fairly new or only relevant to the developments in the version of horde delivered via https://horde-satis.maintain.com – This article will be continuously updated as I have time or relevant questions pop up.

Setup your work environment

A ready-made docker-compose deployment can be downloaded here: https://github.com/maintaina/deployments/
A basic root project for installing horde via composer can be found here: https://github.com/maintaina-com/horde-deployment/

Either way, you should be able to connect into a running sample installation on your local desktop within less than 5 minutes. Visual Studio Code and other editors can directly connect into the container content, so there is no need for fancy mounts etc. Mind each repo’s readme files for instructions.

Horde as viewed by the composer installer

Composer is the installer used for Horde and also does most of the autoloading.

A root project should have at the very least the paths /web/ for all web visible assets, /vendor/ for dependencies and /var/ for both configuration, logs and variable data which should NOT be web-visible.

Besides the default library type, horde comes with a composer plugin to support the types horde-application, horde-theme and horde-library. The /web/ and /vendor/ dirs are under the control of composer, do NOT put any custom content there. It will be deleted with each subsequent update. This is different from the older PEAR installer which would only overwrite files with newer package content, but not remove any custom files not included in the package.

A ready-made docker-compose deployment with some default configuration can be found here:

All horde-application packages are installed to the /web/ dir.
All library, horde-library, horde-theme packages will be installed to the /vendor/ dir.
If a package is a horde-library or a horde-application and has a js/ dir, its contents are symlinked into a structure below web/js/. If a package is a horde-application or a horde-theme, specific links under the /web/themes/ dir are created on install or update. The installer plugin will search for application config files under the /var/config path and link them to /web/$app/config/. The installer will also autogenerate some files under /var/config if they are missing.

Filesystem layout

All Horde applications share the same filesystem layout.

  • /app/controllers/ contains old-style Horde_Controller request handlers.
  • /bin contains commandline scripts or cron jobs, usually prepended by the application name and without the .php suffix – these will automatically linked to the /vendor/bin path unless otherwise declared.
  • /config contains actual defaults files from the package as well as symlinks to user-provided or autogenerated configuration items. The routes.php file goes here.
  • /doc dir contains the license file, changelog.yml file, optionally a CHANGES file and any documentation in RST format. Some documentation can be autogenerated from the horde.org wiki.
  • /js contains ready-to-run Javascript code. Minifying is not necessary as it can be done by horde.
  • /lib dir contains PHP code which is usually unnamespaced and follows the PSR-0 autoloading standard.
  • /locale contains machine-readable PO translation files and the sources from which they are generated.
  • /migration contains code for automated buildup, upgrade and teardown of SQL database schema.
  • /scripts contains upgrade scripts and non-php content like LDIF files or apache config snippets.
  • /src dir contains PHP code following PSR-4 Namespaced Autoloading and PSR-12 Coding Standards.
  • /templates contains PHP and HTML templates mostly for backend-rendered content
  • /test contains unit tests and integration tests built with the phpunit framework.
  • /themes contains css and image files. See separate section on themes.
  • The top dir contains a composer.json manifest, a PEAR package.xml manifest, possibly some README.md and other control files. Traditionally, it housed all the entry points through which the browser would call into PHP code and get server-rendered pages as a result. This is no longer the recommended pattern.

Most of your newly developed code should live somewhere under /src. Libraries follow the same layout.

Web Layout

The general rule is you cannot hardcode any web-visible paths. All assumptions will eventually be wrong.
In a default installation as generated by the installer, the horde base app will be under /horde/ and the login screen will be under /horde/login.php etc. Other applications will be on the same level besides the /horde base app – /turba for the addressbook, /passwd for the password utility etc. Javascript will be visible under /js and themes under /themes – this is, unless you have configured something else. The webroot could be /tools/foo/bar rather than /.
The webmail application could reside under https://imp.foo.org/ rather than https://foo.org/imp. Themes could be presented from a totally different subdomain. The horde backend knows how to autogenerate the appropriate URLs. Your frontend should not make any assumptions.

Translation

Use the horde-translation tool to maintain translations. It generates binary .po files from a human-readable format. PHP can use these files to translate English text to your chosen frontend language. You can expose your frontend language under language-independent keys filled with the appropriate translations. You should NOT maintain translations in your frontend code as translation files can be customized by the administrator.

Themes

Horde can apply themes at runtime. Theme CSS is applied in the following order:

  • Horde global default CSS
  • Horde global custom theme css
  • App-specific default CSS
  • App-specific custom theme css (if present)

This mechanism will break if you use a build process that prepends CSS definitions with build-specific prefixes.
User-provided themes have the composer type horde-theme. The installer will link them to the web/themes folder.

Caching and minifying Javascript

Horde has a runtime javascript bundler and minifier which will bundle all javascript marked for delivery into one file and minify it. This file will be cached into the web-visible static dir. On version update, the file name will change. For this to work, you need to tell the framework which javascript files to include rather than just dish out a static html file with hardcoded paths to the individual JS files.

TODO code example

Caching and minifying themes

Horde has a runtime css minifier and bundler. All CSS will be bundled into a file and minified. This file will be cached in the web-visible static dir. If the user selects another theme, horde will minify and cache a different collection of files. For this to work, you should not hardcode paths to CSS file paths in your HTML templates or frontend code.

TODO code example

The Registry

With this amount of configurability, you need a source of truth about what goes where. This is the Horde Registry.
The registry has an index of all applications, their base web and filesystem location, which RPC and Inter-App APIs they expose, how they are represented in the topbar menu and where their Javascript and Themes resources are available in the local filesystem and as viewed from the web.

Registry Configuration

Querying the Registry

Routes, Middlewares and Handlers

Each application may have a config/routes.php file which contains web-accessible routes relative to this application and.

use Horde\Core\Middleware\AuthHordeSession;
use Horde\Core\Middleware\RedirectToLogin;
use Horde\Passwd\Middleware\RenderReactApp;
use Horde\Core\Middleware\ReturnSessionToken;
use Horde\Core\Middleware\DemandAuthenticatedUser;
use Horde\Core\Middleware\DemandSessionToken;

use Horde\Passwd\Handler\ReactInit;
use Horde\Passwd\Handler\Api\ChangePassword;

$mapper->connect(
    'Api',
    '/api/changepw',
    [
        'controller' => ChangePassword::class,
        'stack' => [
            AuthHordeSession::class,
            DemandAuthenticatedUser::class,
            // DemandSessionToken::class,
        ],
    ]
);

$mapper->connect(
    'ReactInit',
    '/react',
    [
        'controller' => ReactInit::class,
        'stack' => [
            AuthHordeSession::class,
            RedirectToLogin::class,
        ]
    ]
);

This example from a development version of the passwd app shows two routes: /react would hand out a browser page with all the boilerplate to load a Single Page Application UI (SPA). /api/changepw would receive a JSON message and, if the request is valid, change the user’s password. Each route definition contains of a name, a URL pattern and a third parameter defining the controller, the middleware stack or constraints like only processing the route for POST request. A route can also contain placeholders that can expand into variables and defaults for optional parts. Routes are processed in a first-hit-wins strategy so place your specific route definitions before the general cases. All routes are interpreted as relative to the application’s webroot.

The controller can be any string representing a class which is either a traditional Horde_Controller, a PSR-15 Request Handler or a PSR-15 Middleware. The only requirement is that the Injector needs to know how to produce it, either via Autowiring or via some explicit Binder (Factory, Implementation, Annotation …).

The Stack is either an array of strings representing PSR-15 Middlewares or a string recognized by the injector which will produce an iterable list of Middlewares. If there is no stack parameter, a default stack will be applied: Only allow requests for authenticated users identified by session cookie, forward everybody else to the login page. If you do not want any middlewares before your controller, explicitly set stack to an empty array. The middleware stack will be executed top to bottom before the controller is called and the request can be modified in that phase. If any middleware decides to answer your request by itself, no further middlewares will be called and the controller will not be executed. Responses travel back upward through the middleware stack and can be modified during that phase.

Lifecycle of a browser session

A typical user session would go like this:

  • A user navigates to webroot or any application route
  • As his browser provides no valid session cookie, he is redirected to the login page
  • The user enters credentials into the login form and posts a request. This will create a valid session cookie
  • The user is forwarded to his desired route or a default route
  • The backend sends all the HTML, CSS, graphics and javascript required to show the requested page. Javascript and CSS are each minified and bundled into cache files. Also, the framework inserts a javascript variable with dynamic data like the location of the API endpoints, chosen UI language etc.
  • User interactions either trigger ajax requests to API routes or forward him to a location outside the Single Page Application (i.e. another horde app or someplace outside). For ajax requests which change backend content, another credential besides the cookie is needed, for example a custom header with the session key or a special write token.
  • Eventually, the user logs out and his session will be invalidated

Permissions system

Administrator users

Shares

Preferences

Configuration System

Virtual Host specific configuration

Inter-App API and RPC

Special classes

ORM Layer horde/rdo

bookmark_borderCustom iCalendar data in Kronolith & Nag

The iCalendar exchange format is everywhere in Horde’s calendar (kronolith) and tasks (nag) apps. It is offered for manual import/export. It is the centerpiece of the CalDAV synchronisation protocol and various APIs of these apps. The format also plays a role in email invitiations and updates sent via iTip. It is a very powerful and well-accepted format. This is, unfortunately, a little bit of a problem. Fortunately, we also have a solution

The iCalendar format was originally defined by the IETF. They released RFC 2445 back in 1998. While Horde still understands that format, a newer version 2.0 was defined in RFC 5545 in 2009. An extension to the 2.0 standard was released in 2016: RFC 7986 defines additional attributes needed to describe related conferencing software resources or other technical aspects.

Server and client software has always been free to add custom attributes to the different components of the standard. For example, Horde Kronolith stores and reads a special attribute X-HORDE-ATTENDEE to mark event attendees who have a horde user attached. Mozilla uses attributes like X-MOZ-LASTACK and MS Exchange comes with a long list of custom attributes, among them X-CALEND. Understanding these attributes when processing a icalendar file is optional. However, servers are expected not to silently drop attributes they do not understand.

Up until now, both Kronolith and Nag did support a wide range of attributes, but far from all. Events are reconstructed from calendar backend contents. Unsupported data simply gets lost. As it is technically impossible to know all attributes anybody out there may use, the opposite definition was needed: An attribute is an “other” attribute if it is not in the list of attributes the app already handles. Both apps got a catalog of attributes they understand and a property for storing everything else. Support for actually storing and retrieving this data is currently limited to the SQL backend. I do not currently invest time in Kolab support, maybe I will never do that.

Also, while I took care to ensure that normal editing via the UI will not break the “other” data, I did not cross check with scenarios where ActiveSync is involved. Please report bugs as you find them.

CalDAV event Storage

For kronolith, an optional storage of unmodified caldav events as received has been added during development. I am not sure if I will keep this or remove it again. It is useful for debugging various support scenarios but under normal operation, it is not required. It may be useful for creating a cache of external caldav calendars though.

Extend to Turba Addressbook

Turba Addressbook uses a similar data format vcard and implements the sister protocol CardDAV. Things are indeed a little more complicated. There are three relevant versions of vcard 2.1, 3.0 and 4.0 and multiple extension RFCs with additional contact attributes exist. Worse, there is a host of X- attributes from popular desktop addressbook vendors, Evolution, Kontact, Thunderbird, Android, MS Exchange/Outlook… There are at least two different ways to represent contact groups and the whole thing is a little messy. But the real problem lies with Turba’s highly configurable nature. At least two backends need to be upgraded: Both SQL storage and LDAP play a key role in typical Turba use cases. The exact layout of each addressbook can be different even inside the same installation. The list of vcard attributes considered as natively supported needs to be calculated for each addressbook and additional attributes maybe need to be stored outside of the specific backend. This will take some time and consideration.

Still, Turba’s tendency to forget what it does not care for needs to be addressed. Otherwise users risk losing attributes on sync.

bookmark_borderMaintaina Horde switches to openSUSE LEAP

Our Horde docker images have switched over from Tumbleweed to openSUSE LEAP once again.

Recently our container build CI job in github.com broke down unexpectedly. An investigation showed that Tumbleweed’s core libraries, especially libc, were too new for the CI’s build system, based on Ubuntu LTS.

This is the second time we abandoned the Tumbleweed basis for Horde docker containers. OpenSUSE Leap 15.3 uses a relatively old, but well-maintained, set of base libraries. Both Leap and Tumbleweed deliver PHP 7.4 as a basis for Horde. In both systems, we skip the packaged composer version for a static pick which we will update from time to time. We may switch over to packaged composer if we feel confident.

For users and administrators of the image, both Tumbleweed and Leap 15.3 should feel more or less the same. For end users of the delivered horde setup, there should not be any downsides. We will switch back to the Tumbleweed image in a while when we have picked a more recent version of Ubuntu.